Chinese or Japanese: which to learn, and how the languages and characters differ

Chinese or Japanese is not a choice between an "easy" language and a "hard" one; it's a choice between different kinds of hard. The two languages aren't related: they have different grammar, different sounds and different words. What they share is the characters, which Japan borrowed from China long ago. So the honest answer to "which is better, Chinese or Japanese?" is this: the one you need for your work, or the one you're genuinely curious about.
Chinese vs Japanese vs Korean: a comparison
People usually choose between three languages, so Korean is in the table too. It isn't related to Chinese or Japanese either, although its grammar is very similar to Japanese.
| What we compare | Chinese | Japanese | Korean |
|---|---|---|---|
| Writing system | Characters only | Characters plus two syllabic scripts (kana) | The Hangul alphabet |
| Tones | Yes: four plus a neutral tone | No, but there is a pitch accent | No |
| Grammar | Word order like English: who, does, what. Words never change form | Verb at the end, many endings and politeness levels | Verb at the end, endings and politeness levels |
| Pronunciation for an English speaker | The tones and a handful of sounds are hard | Easier: few sounds, almost all familiar | A few unfamiliar consonants and vowels |
| How soon you can speak | Simple sentences come together fast, if you get the tones right early | Easy to pronounce, but a sentence needs verb forms | Like Japanese: endings first, then sentences |
| How soon you can read | Slowest: every word is characters you have to learn | Kana in a few weeks; real texts only once you know the characters | Fastest: the letters take a few days |
The table shows the main point: in each language something comes almost for free, and something else costs you time. In Chinese the grammar is cheap and the writing and pronunciation are expensive. In Japanese and Korean it's the other way round.
Chinese vs Japanese characters: what's the difference
Chinese and Japanese characters are one and the same set of signs that drifted apart over the centuries. In mainland China the characters were simplified in the middle of the last century: they lost strokes. Taiwan and Hong Kong still write the old way, with traditional characters. Japan ran its own reform: some characters it simplified the same way as China, some in its own way, and some it left as they were.
| China | Japan | Taiwan, Hong Kong | Meaning | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 学 | 学 | 學 | to study | China and Japan simplified it the same way |
| 国 | 国 | 國 | country | China and Japan simplified it the same way |
| 气 | 気 | 氣 | air, spirit | Three different forms |
| 图 | 図 | 圖 | picture, diagram | Three different forms |
| 书 | 書 | 書 | book; to write | Japan kept the old form |
The second difference matters more than the first: a character may look alike, but it's read completely differently. Here are words written with the very same characters in both languages:
- 学生xuéshengstudentsame characters in Japanese, read gakusei
- 大学dàxuéuniversitysame characters in Japanese, read daigaku
- 中国ZhōngguóChinasame characters in Japanese, read Chūgoku
- 天气tiānqìweatherin Japanese 天気, read tenki
In Chinese a character almost always has a single reading: learn and you read it that way in every word. A Japanese character usually has several readings: one came from China along with the character, another is a native Japanese word that was written with it. The same 学 is read gaku in the word for "student" and mana- in the verb "to learn". Only the whole word tells you which reading to use.
And the third difference: in Japanese text, characters are mixed with the kana syllabaries. Kana is used for endings, grammar words and loanwords. Chinese text is solid characters with no spaces. How the characters themselves are built and what they're made of is covered in the article about radicals.
Can Chinese people read Japanese, and Japanese people read Chinese?
Individual words and the gist of a sign, yes. "Exit", "hospital", "university", "prohibited" are written with the same or very similar characters, and someone from the neighboring country will recognize them. Connected text, no: a Chinese reader sees familiar roots in a Japanese sentence, but all the grammar is hidden in kana they can't read. A Japanese reader recognizes some of the characters in Chinese text, but the simplified forms and unfamiliar grammar words soon throw them off.
There are traps, too: identical characters with different meanings. In Chinese 手纸 means "toilet paper", while Japanese 手紙 is "a letter". And by ear the languages are nothing alike: Chinese and Japanese speakers can't understand each other's speech.
Which is harder: Chinese or Japanese?
It depends on what you find harder. It's easier to compare piece by piece.
- Chinese: the pronunciation and the number of characters are hard. The tone decides what a word means, and the first weeks go into learning to hear them; there's a separate article on tones. To read everyday texts you need around three thousand characters. The grammar, on the other hand, is simple: no verb conjugations at all (not even "I go / he goes"), no plural endings, no tenses built into the verb, and the word order of a simple sentence is the same as in English.
- Japanese: the grammar and reading the characters are hard. The sounds are simple, there are no tones, and you can repeat a sentence after a speaker from day one. But the verb comes at the end, it has many forms, and you say the same thing differently to a friend, a colleague and a customer. You need around two thousand characters to read, fewer than in Chinese, but each one has several readings.
- Korean: a fast start, then grammar. The alphabet takes a few days, and right away you can read anything aloud, even if you don't understand it yet. After that comes grammar of the same kind as Japanese: endings, particles and politeness levels.
If sounds and music come easily to you but you hate tables of endings, Chinese may turn out simpler than its reputation. If it's the other way round, you'll feel more at home in Japanese. The hard and easy sides of Chinese are covered in detail in Is Chinese hard to learn?.
How to choose between Chinese and Japanese
The most reliable way is to choose by goal: it's what will keep you going in the second and third year, once the novelty wears off.
- Work and trade. Look at which country your field is connected to. Sourcing, logistics, manufacturing and working with suppliers lead to Chinese more often. Chinese is also the most widely spoken native language in the world. Japanese is for people who work with Japanese companies specifically.
- Study. Pick the language of the country where you want to study, and find out right away which exam they ask for. For Chinese universities it's the HSK; you can see what the first level covers in the HSK 1 word list.
- Culture and media. If you watch anime and read manga, learn Japanese; if you listen to K-pop and watch K-dramas, Korean; if you're drawn to Chinese dramas, history or calligraphy, Chinese. Material you love gives you daily practice without any willpower.
- Moving abroad. Here the choice is made for you: you need the language of the country you'll live in.
If there's no clear goal, follow your motivation. A language you like the sound and look of, you'll open every day; a "useful" one that leaves you cold, you'll drop within a month. Try each for a week and see which one you want to come back to.
Can you learn Chinese and Japanese at the same time?
As a beginner, better not. The characters will start to blur: you'd have to memorize the same character with two readings, sometimes with two spellings and different meanings. Each language would get half the time, and both need daily practice.
It's wiser to build a solid base in one language first, to the point where you read simple texts and don't stop to think about common characters. After that, the second language goes noticeably faster: the characters are already familiar, and all that's left is attaching new sounds to them. If you start with Chinese, it pays to learn stroke order from the start; the writing practice sheets check it, and the skill carries over entirely to Japanese characters.
Try Chinese in five minutes
The first lesson is "The four tones": you hear how the melody changes the meaning of a word. Free during the beta with an account.
Take the first lesson

